Techniques
Sample rules
Entra ID Potential Passkey Downgrade
- source: elastic
- technicques:
- T1078
- T1550
- T1556
- T1557
Description
Identifies a Microsoft Entra ID user whose recent fresh authentications are predominantly phishing-resistant (passkey/FIDO2 or Windows Hello for Business) but who then successfully completes a phishable method such as Authenticator push, OATH, SMS, or voice. Adversary-in-the-middle proxies force this downgrade by suppressing the passkey prompt so the victim falls back to a relayable method. Legitimate fallback produces the same pattern, so the alert requires corroboration.
Detection logic
FROM logs-azure.signinlogs-*
| WHERE azure.signinlogs.category == "SignInLogs"
AND azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id IS NOT NULL
AND azure.signinlogs.properties.authentication_details IS NOT NULL
AND azure.signinlogs.properties.user_id IS NOT NULL
AND azure.signinlogs.properties.user_principal_name IS NOT NULL
AND azure.signinlogs.properties.tenant_id IS NOT NULL
// Pair each authentication method with its success flag from the flattened authentication_details
| EVAL ad = TO_STRING(azure.signinlogs.properties.authentication_details)
| GROK ad """"authentication_method":%{DATA:method_raw},"authentication_"""
| GROK ad """"succeeded":%{DATA:succeeded_raw}}"""
| EVAL Esql.auth_methods = SPLIT(REPLACE(method_raw, """[\[\]"]""", ""), ","),
Esql.auth_method_succeeded = SPLIT(REPLACE(succeeded_raw, """[\[\]"]""", ""), ",")
| EVAL Esql.method_outcome_pairs = MV_CONCAT(MV_ZIP(Esql.auth_methods, Esql.auth_method_succeeded, "~"), " || ")
// Flag sessions where a phishing-resistant or a phishable method actually succeeded (passkey/WHfB vs push/OATH/SMS/voice)
| EVAL Esql.resistant_method_success = CASE(
Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*Passkey (synced)~true*" OR Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*Passkey (device-bound)~true*"
OR Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*FIDO2 security key~true*" OR Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*Windows Hello for Business~true*", 1, 0),
Esql.phishable_method_success = CASE(
Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*Mobile app notification~true*" OR Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*OATH verification code~true*"
OR Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*Text message~true*" OR Esql.method_outcome_pairs LIKE "*Voice call~true*", 1, 0)
// A downgrade event is a phishable method succeeding within the recent window
| EVAL Esql.is_downgrade = Esql.phishable_method_success == 1 AND @timestamp >= NOW() - 24 hour
// Aggregate session counts and downgrade-event context by tenant and user
| STATS Esql.total_sessions = COUNT_DISTINCT(azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id),
Esql.resistant_sessions = COUNT_DISTINCT(CASE(Esql.resistant_method_success == 1, azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id, null)),
Esql.phishable_sessions = COUNT_DISTINCT(CASE(Esql.phishable_method_success == 1, azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id, null)),
Esql.baseline_resistant = COUNT_DISTINCT(CASE(Esql.resistant_method_success == 1 AND @timestamp < NOW() - 24 hour, azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id, null)),
Esql.baseline_phishable = COUNT_DISTINCT(CASE(Esql.phishable_method_success == 1 AND @timestamp < NOW() - 24 hour, azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id, null)),
Esql.downgrade_session_count = COUNT_DISTINCT(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id, null)),
Esql.last_seen = MAX(@timestamp),
Esql.downgrade_methods = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, Esql.method_outcome_pairs, null)),
Esql.downgrade_sessions = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.session_id, null)),
Esql.downgrade_ips = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, source.ip, null)),
Esql.downgrade_as_orgs = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, source.`as`.organization.name, null)),
Esql.downgrade_countries = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, source.geo.country_name, null)),
Esql.downgrade_user_agents = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, user_agent.original, null)),
Esql.downgrade_device_os = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.device_detail.operating_system, null)),
Esql.downgrade_apps = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.app_display_name, null)),
Esql.downgrade_resources = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.resource_display_name, null)),
Esql.downgrade_client_apps = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.client_app_used, null)),
Esql.downgrade_ca_status = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.conditional_access_status, null)),
Esql.downgrade_risk_states = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.risk_state, null)),
Esql.downgrade_correlation_ids = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, azure.signinlogs.properties.correlation_id, null)),
Esql.downgrade_outcomes = VALUES(CASE(Esql.is_downgrade, event.outcome, null))
BY azure.signinlogs.properties.tenant_id, azure.signinlogs.properties.user_principal_name, azure.signinlogs.properties.user_id
// Require a minimum resistant baseline (sessions older than 24h) and at least one recent downgrade
| WHERE Esql.baseline_resistant >= 3 AND Esql.downgrade_session_count >= 1
// Phishing-resistant ratio over the baseline only, so the downgrade session should not dilute it (token-reuse / unresolved sessions excluded)
| EVAL Esql.unknown_sessions = Esql.total_sessions - Esql.phishable_sessions - Esql.resistant_sessions,
Esql.fresh_auth_sessions = Esql.resistant_sessions + Esql.phishable_sessions,
Esql.resistant_ratio = Esql.baseline_resistant::double / (Esql.baseline_resistant + Esql.baseline_phishable)
// Keep predominantly phishing-resistant users (>= 90%)
| WHERE Esql.resistant_ratio >= 0.9
| KEEP azure.*, Esql.*